What is integrated parasite management?
Integrated parasite management is a strategy to manage the parasites affecting our sheep to minimize losses and maximize the effectiveness of our chemical dewormers in the event of clinical illness. The illusion that we will ever eliminate parasites is fortunately becoming a thing of the past. Instead we are considering populations of parasites much as we consider rumen bacteria; they are an important group of organisms that need particular care to be a functional and non-detrimental part of our flock. There is compelling research suggesting that because sheep and their internal parasites evolved together, a sheep’s immune system functions better in the presence of a small parasite burden. In other words, worms can be friends and not foes if we play our cards right.
In this article we will discuss why this is so important, what you need to know about parasite physiology and life cycle, as well as tools to reduce your parasite burden and preserve a population of parasites that are susceptible to as-needed deworming. While I focus on sheep, the following information is applicable to all small ruminants and camelids.
Why does it matter?
Internal parasites represent the single most widespread and significant health concern for small ruminants. They affect sheep on all six continents where sheep are found. In sheep, they lead to a range of health concerns including, but not limited to: diarrhea, rumen stasis, anemia, neurological disease, pulmonary (lung) disease, and sudden death. They can challenge producers by causing animals to lose weight, not gain properly (ill-thrift), or have poor reproductive performance.
Current conditions like increased farming density, management styles that increase metabolic and emotional stress, climate change leading to extended temperate seasons for parasites to thrive in, and misuse of chemical dewormers selecting for multidrug resistance have exacerbated the internal parasite problem. While some of these conditions may seem hard to address, each of us has the power to minimize the risk to our flock from internal parasites through simple and effective changes in our perspective, management, and individual animal treatments.
Antihelminth resistance
The definition of antihelminth resistance is failure to reduce fecal parasite egg counts by 95% or more. It is a condition in which our dewormers will no longer be able to treat animals who are clinically ill from internal parasites. In the United States, there are many flocks and herds and indeed entire bioregions–like the South East United States–where this problem has reached epidemic proportions. How has this happened?
Parasites, bacteria and viruses all have innate properties, like genes, that are intrinsic to them and are present from birth or replication. These properties help them navigate and survive in the world. In the case of internal parasites, some of these properties confer resistance to our antihelminth (dewormer) medications. When we deworm improperly–for instance, with too much frequency, improper dosing, or too many animals at once–we are placing selection pressure on the parasites. We are killing the parasites that are susceptible to our dewormers and leaving behind a population that survived our deworming, and will therefore breed and create offspring that will carry the genes that allow them to survive our deworming. The net result is that our dewormers become less and less effective at higher and higher doses.
Antihelminth resistance is demonstrated in every class of dewormer that we currently have available. No new classes of dewormers have been introduced in the last 30 years in the United States, and more importantly NONE ARE ON THEIR WAY. I have talked to many producers who are continuing to deworm using outdated methods and just hoping that a new miracle product will come out before there is no dewormer left to use in their herd. I cannot stress enough how unlikely this is at this point. There have been new products, but they are the same classes of dewormers dressed in different coats. For the most part, resistance to a single drug within a class means at least some resistance to that entire class.
What are the practices that contribute the most to antihelminth resistance?
The following is a list that some of my more seasoned producers reading this article might find shocking. These are the practices that contribute most to the selection of antihelminth resistant parasites. Many of the practices used to be, and some unfortunately still are, widely recommended. However, they must be changed if we want to continue having effective medical treatments for serious parasitic infections. The practices that contribute the most to making our dewormers ineffective include:
Frequent deworming
Treating the entire flock on a schedule
Improper dosing
Injectable and pour on dewormers
Feed additive dewormers
Putting treated animals on a clean pasture (dry lotting)
Improper storage
Using single dewormers
If this list sends a chill up your spine because it contains several of your current practices
Image from Douglas Adam’s Hitchhikers Guide to the Galaxy
We are going to dive into current recommendations in all of these areas and hopefully leave you with some new tools and strategies to stop or mitigate any damage that has been done.
Your friend, the parasite
As we mentioned in the introduction, we cannot rid the world of small ruminant parasites. Instead we should approach them as a population to help manage. The first step is to understand who the major players are, how they infect our sheep, and what diseases occur when they do.
Sheep can be infected with several types of parasites, sometimes with multiple kinds simultaneously. For example, nematodes (roundworms like haemonchus contortus), cestodes (tapeworms), trematodes (like liver flukes), or single celled protozoa (coccidia, giardia, cryptosporidium) can coexist at the same time. Nematodes, trematodes, and cestodes comprise the helminths and are our primary focus in this article, although we will devote a bit of attention to the single celled protozoa, who are certainly a problem depending on your flock and management style.
Strongyles have short, direct life cycles that depend on temperature and moisture. Direct life cycle means they do not require an intermediate host, they can directly infect the sheep from the pasture. They are able to overwinter on pasture because of their ability to enter a hypobiotic (metabolic arrest) state when external conditions would normally not allow them to survive or develop. Strongyles love warm, wet weather. Temperate regions allow their eggs to easily survive over winter. The living egg count in a field will spike during warmer wetter months, leading to a larger potential worm burden in your sheep. Unfortunately, the warm, wet spring coincides with ewes having lower immunity due to pregnancy or young lambs with underdeveloped immune systems. This can lead to a perfect storm if not managed carefully.
All strongyle eggs look essentially the same under a microscope i.e. when doing fecal egg tests. This means we need other diagnostics to differentiate them. Fortunately, when chemical dewormers that kill strongyles are working optimally, it is generally not necessary to know exactly which strongyle you are dealing with.
Typical illnesses caused by strongyle infection carry signs like diarrhea, weight loss, ill thrift, lethargy, runny nose, cough, and if not addressed, a slow, wasting death. However, there is one very important strongyle which has markedly different signs. The barber pole worm, Haemonchus Contortus, is a worm that embeds in the true stomach (abomasum) of small ruminants and sucks their host’s blood. This parasite can cause life-threatening anemia and a very quick demise. Sometimes, the only sign a shepherd sees is a dead sheep that seemed perfectly healthy the day before. For a closer look at this specific strongyle, please check out this article.
Cestodes, or tapeworms, are the only sheep parasite that you can see in the feces with your naked eye. They have an indirect life cycle, meaning they require a mite as an indirect host. Immunity to these visually disgusting, but primarily harmless parasites develops in the lamb at an early age. They rarely cause disease, and if they do there is almost certainly an underlying tax on the immune system. Research also shows that treating for tapeworms is not particularly beneficial in sheep. Treating for tapeworms, if they are not actually causing illness, can put selection pressure on other, more harmful parasites like Haemonchus Contortus and Fasciola Hepatica, and contribute to resistance.
Trematodes, the family containing liver flukes (Fasciola hepatica), are generally only present in wet, poorly-drained pastures. They are very much a regional problem at this point; for example, in the pacific northwest of the United States. They also have an indirect lifecycle requiring a slug or snail as an intermediate host. They are blood feeders like the barber pole worm and can cause anemia, lethargy, ill thrift, bottle jaw (submandibular edema), and death. While these can cause serious disease, they are also often found incidentally at slaughter when the liver, looking a bit like swiss cheese, is condemned for teaming with them. Valbazen is generally the dewormer of choice for these guys.
Coccidia is an example of a single-celled protozoa that can wreak total havoc on young lambs and other young animals. Coccidia are species specific; sheep do not get goat coccidia and goats do not get sheep coccidia. Adults can often have a small coccidia burden but it will not cause disease unless there is an underlying immune issue. The main sign of this protozoa is DIARRHEA and plenty of it. Coccidia causes severe dehydration, nutrient malabsorption, and death in young animals. Weaning is a common time to see this disease manifest due to stress, and potentially overcrowding or poor hygiene.
The signs of coccidiosis are foul smelling diarrhea with blood or mucus in it, dags (poop covered bum), hocks and tail, poor coat, depression, anorexia, dehydration, anemia, and death. It is 100% a management issue. You cannot get coccidia without eating poop. Feeding above the ground and good hygiene around lambing, especially in pens where lambs are kept, is your number one ally in the fight against coccidiosis. Coccidiosis is generally treated with Amprolium or Sulfa drugs, and sometimes during certain critical outbreaks will require treatments of dams around parturition, even if they are asymptomatic, to keep them from shedding coccidia that will then infect the lambs. Many farms feed coccidiastats in the normal feed to their lambs or their entire flock. As a veterinarian, I can say that this may occasionally have a place but in general, feed additive antiparasitics contribute to resistance and can never make up for changes in management that get sheep out of areas where they are forced to eat poop.
Your toolbox
Now that you have been introduced and potentially horrified by some of what you are up against in the small ruminant parasite department, let’s look at some of the essential tools you can use to mitigate risk and minimize use of chemical dewormers. The first thing a shepherd who is committed to responsible use of antihelminthics needs to get comfortable with is deciding who needs to be treated. Why? Because we no longer deworm whole flocks on a schedule. The practice of deworming animals that are not being negatively impacted by their worm burdens is the single biggest contributing factor to our chemical dewormers becoming useless in the face of serious disease. FAMACHA in conjunction with a 5 point check is the foundation of deciding who is being impacted negatively by parasites and therefore needs to be treated, or potentially culled.
FAMACHA is a technique for assessing anemia which has been validated in sheep, goats, and South American camelids. It was developed by small scale sheep farmers in South Africa in response to dewormer resistance. Anemia is the primary sign that will develop prior to death in the case of deadly Haemonchus Contortus infections. The technique “COVER-PUSH-PULL-POP” exposes the lower, inner eye conjunctiva for comparison against cards which are standardized and printed through one of a few universities world wide. How often animals need to be checked depends on the time of year, the species, the climate, and the history of the flock. To learn this technique, you can either take a free online training or one of several in person trainings that happen each year. There are plenty of youtube videos, but most of them do not actually show proper technique, simply holding the eye open does not expose the correct tissue, rather it shows an outer layer subject to variation among different individuals. The inner tissue is what has been shown to correlate with the degree of anemia. Also, do not print your own cards from photos. All printers are different, and the variation may mean miscategorizing your animals. The cards cost about 16 dollars and you are able to order them as soon as you have completed an official online or in person training.
Because anemia is only caused by a couple of internal parasites, it is important we are also monitoring for other signs. The five point check is a quick tool to evaluate the entire animal from nose to tail.
1=Nose
Is the nose runny?
2=Eye
FAMACHA score
3=Jaw
Signs of bottle jaw or swelling under the jaw
4=Back
BCS score, general condition
5=Tail
Dag score (degree to which an animal may be experiencing diarrhea)
Getting in the habit of checking these 5 parameters regularly can help us catch signs of illness associated with internal parasites early and make necessary adjustments or provide appropriate treatments. Some people add a sixth point, which is coat or fleece. The condition of the wool in wool breeds is a great parameter to watch for overall health.
FAMACHA and the 5 point check may be too time consuming for very large flocks, and yet they are afflicted with the same troubles involving antihelminth resistance. For this reason, shepherds over in Europe and New Zealand have tried to create a quick and simple system for selectively deworming large flocks. This method is called “The Happy Factor,” its tagline is that a healthy sheep is a happy sheep. This is a performance-based tool that considers factors such as weight gain and milk production. When animals fail to meet production targets, they are dewormed. In the UK, the system is most successfully employed in groups of animals who have individual electronic identification that communicates with automatic weighing platforms in chutes, then the animals are kicked out into separate groups based on whether or not they will be dewormed.
Fecal Egg Count is a time honoured tool that is valuable, but also often misused. A fecal egg count is the process of placing poop in a solution so it can be evaluated under a microscope for the number of eggs present per a particular volume. It is an assessment of the parasite burden of individual animals. Fecal egg counts are not for deciding which animals to treat in the absence of clinical signs. Fecal egg counts are for determining if your dewormers are working as you hope, for confirming that non specific signs like ill thrift you are seeing are likely related to a parasitic infection, to select animals for breeding/culling based on their resistance (low fecal egg count), or resilience (higher fecal egg count without clinical signs). Also, certain animals are super shedders. Within any given flock 20% of the animals carry 80% of the flock’s collective parasite burden. Choosing to cull these animals can greatly reduce the eggs being shed in your pastures and barns, potentially harming vulnerable animals like pregnant ewes and lambs.
When fecal egg counts are used to assess how well dewormers are working, it is called a fecal egg reduction test. Fecal egg counts are done prior to deworming, and then 10-14 days after treatment with dewormers. Antihelminth resistance in parasites is defined as a failure to reduce the fecal egg count in an individual animal by at least 95%. Ideally, a minimum of 15 samples for each dewormer being tested in your animals will give the most accurate picture of where you are at in terms of resistance in parasites to dewormers. Here are the most recent guidelines published for proper technique and use of fecal egg reduction tests.
Chemical dewormers are absolutely still in the toolbox, even if you are dealing with a degree of antihelminth resistance in your flock. When used frugally and correctly, they are invaluable. There are three classes of dewormers. Cross resistance is common among dewormers in the same class, for instance parasites which are resistant to Ivermectin will likely have some degree of resistance to Moxidectin (trade name Cydectin). The first class is Benzimidazoles which include products like Safeguard (Fenbendazole), Valbazen (Albendazole), and Synanthic (Oxfendazole). The second class is Acrocytic Lactones which includes Avermectins like Ivermectin and Doramectin, and Milbemycins like Cydectin or Quest (both Moxidectin). The third group is Nocotinic agonists and includes Imidazothiazoles like Prohibit (Levamisole), and Tetrahydropyrmidines like Strongid (Pyrantel).
Recommendations for the proper use of chemical dewormers include selective treatment based on FAMACHA scores and 5 point checks, using combination treatment, using proper dosing, and defending and growing a refugia. Combination treatment refers to using a dewormer from each of these three classes in conjunction to treat a clinically ill animal. It is different then rotating dewormers or using a different dewormer each time you deworm everyone on a schedule. Rotating dewormers is a very effective method of creating resistance to every class of dewormers in your parasite population, creating a scenario where animals will die of previously treatable infections.
Using combinations of dewormers, one after the other–not mixed together–creates a synergistic effect. Higher efficacy means there are fewer resistant worms surviving to breed into your larger population of parasites who are still susceptible to dewormers. This population is known as your refugia. Therefore, the genes that confer resistance to dewormers are more greatly diluted. Combination therapies are effective and important but they should only be used when SELECTIVELY deworming. If one absolutely insists on deworming the entire flock on a schedule, despite all you are learning, then do not use combination therapies. When using combinations of dewormers use the following principles:
Do not mix the drugs, give them one after the other
Use the most powerful product you can from each class
Give full doses
Always use oral drenches
Observe the withdrawal period for meat and milk that is longest among the products you are using
Only selectively deworm–never deworm everyone and never on a schedule
Place wormed animals on “dirty” pasture i.e. within their refugia
Refugia is a very important concept when we are managing parasite populations to make sure they will remain susceptible to our dewormers. Refugia refers to the worms, both inside of live animals and out on our pastures, that have not been exposed to dewormers and therefore remain susceptible to them. Refugia is important because the majority of resistance to our dewormers within parasites is contained in recessive genes. In other words, both parents must be resistant to dewormers to confer the trait on their offspring. No dewormer, or combination of dewormers, will ever kill 100% of the worms in an animal. Selectively deworming only sick animals with combination therapy and placing those animals back within the refugia will greatly reduce the successful continuation of traits which allow parasites to survive our dewormer.
Now let’s touch on “natural” dewormers. This term encompasses a wide range of substances. Some of these substances have a body of evidence to support their safe use and efficacy, like copper oxide particles and worm killing fungi. Others are used based on the practical experience of producers but do not have scientific research that supports their use. Still, others are products capitalizing on consumer desires and fears and are not efficacious and, in some cases, are also not safe. These products are not benign just because they are so-called natural. They can have properties that may be harmful in and of themselves, or in conjunction with other treatments. However, products like copper oxide particles, as well as certain herbs and herbal formulas can reduce the frequency of our need for chemical dewormers. It is essential to remember that, regardless of the methods we are using to reduce the parasite population or to deworm individuals: nothing replaces the need for regular monitoring of symptoms and appropriate management.
Copper oxide wire particles (COWPs) can reduce barber pole worm populations in both sheep and goats. All copper is not created equally. COWPs contain a slow-release, poorly-absorbed form of copper making them much less likely to lead to copper toxicity if used as directed. Copper sulfate or high copper minerals should not be used in place of COWPs as these products pose a serious risk of copper toxicity in our sheep. While resistance to COWPs has not yet been demonstrated in parasites, experts are concerned that this is possible and want to encourage producers to use the lowest effective dose in lambs and kids and to practice the principles of selective treatment, just as we do with our chemical dewormers. COWPs have also been shown to improve the efficacy of chemical dewormers making them a valuable adjunct treatment especially in flocks where antihelminth resistance has been shown. The best way to make sure that you are staying in safe copper ranges for your sheep is to periodically submit samples of the liver or kidney for mineral analysis. Do this at slaughter time or if you have an animal pass away.
Duddingtonia flagrans is a naturally occurring fungus that is lethal to roundworm larvae in the fields. When it is consumed by our livestock, it reduces the worm burden in the pastures, which lowers fecal egg counts and the need for chemically deworming individuals. This fungus is available as a feed-through product. Sheep eat it and then spread it around the pastures in their feces. There are two available products containing this product. One is BioWorma and requires a veterinarian in the US, and one is Livamol with BioWorma. It is an over the counter medicine. The products are safe for sheep to eat, they have no meat or milk withdrawal time, and the fungus dies after consuming the larvae in the dropped feces–it does not establish itself in the environment. This product does not kill parasites inside the animal, therefore animals who are showing clinical signs of parasitism still need to be treated appropriately.
Certain forages also have antiparasitic properties and can be introduced to pastures so that when grazed, they reduce the parasite population. The most widely studied of this is Sericea Lespedeza. This is a non-bloating, perennial legume that grows very well even in poor soil. Consuming this plant as 25% of the diet has been shown to reduce internal parasites and their clinical effects in both sheep and goats. This effect is seen regardless of whether the plant is fed fresh or as hay, silage, or pellets. Unfortunately, depending on where you live, this plant may be classified as invasive and therefore may be illegal to propagate intentionally.
Management This is a huge topic that requires a more in-depth look by each shepherd so decisions can be made that work best for their particular flock and fields. A few general principles to consider are:
Planning for birth/weaning when parasite burdens are low
Increased monitoring around susceptible times
For example, pregnant ewes often experience a periparturient rise in parasitism due to lowered immunity
Postpose weaning of pasture-raised animals to reduce stress
Prioritizing adequate nutrition at all times
Protein and energy supplementation
Appropriate body condition for production stage
High quality mineral supplementation specific to your species and geographic area
Pasture management can also play a vital role in reducing the parasite burden. Rotational grazing that is of short duration (3-4 days) and has long rest periods (2-3 months) between, is ideal, though impractical for some situations. 3-4 days is the minimum time it takes for parasite eggs to develop into larvae and the long rest period will decrease, though depending on climate and the hypobiotic potential of your parasites, not eliminate the population. Grazing young or vulnerable stock first can minimize their exposure to larvae. Implementing a minimum grazing height, or only grazing animals on grass that is over 4 inches high, is preferred. The vast majority of parasites are present in the first 2-4 inches of growth.
There are also certain breeds which are innately resistant to parasitism due to where they were developed. For example, hair sheep that were developed in tropical regions generally have much lower incidences of disease due to internal parasites than, for instance, our British breeds. While this is a general rule, there tends to be more variation within a breed than between breeds due to current management and recent genetic decisions. Parasite resistance in sheep is 20-40% heritable and therefore, you can choose to select for that trait when choosing whose genetics you will propagate in your flock.
In areas with widespread parasitic resistance to deworming, breeding for animals that have resistance and resilience to parasitic infection may be the only way forward with sheep. Resistance means not having a high worm burden, these are animals which have not been dewormed but maintain low fecal egg counts. Resilience is having a worm burden but not getting sick from it. These animals’ health are not correlated with their fecal egg counts. These animals are identified by low FAMACHA scores and adequate 5 point checks. Also, choosing to cull animals with astronomical fecal egg counts will reduce your parasite burden dramatically. The 80/20 rule refers to the demonstrated phenomena of 20% of any given flock being responsible for 80% of the worm burden.
Conclusion
Each of these topics is worthy of an entire tome. The majority of the information contained in this article is the result of the hard work of members of the American Consortium for Small Ruminant Parasite Control. Their website contains the most comprehensive and up to date information about internal parasites of sheep, goats and camelids as well as management and treatment. I encourage any shepherd to explore their website (wormx.info) for the following:
Management practice fact sheets
Topic articles
Weekly posts
Scientific articles
Image and video library
List of certified FAMACHA instructors, online and in-person upcoming training
TONS of instructional materials for self learning and sharing
There is no world in which internal parasites do not exist within and around our sheep. Acceptance of this reality is the first step to creating a comprehensive program for managing the parasites that affect your flock. Each of the tools outlined in this article will reduce the overall parasite burden, and when many tools are combined appropriately, we can finally put the days of scheduled, widescale drenching and animals succumbing to previously treatable infections behind us.



